logo logo
  • What I do
    • Design Thinking
    • Wicked Problems
    • Studio thinking
  • Work With Me
    • Courses
    • Consulting
    • Keynotes
    • One-on-one
  • Who I work with
  • Videos
  • Articles
  • FREE E-Book
  • Shop
    • Working From Home Book
    • WIcked Wisdom Book
      • Wicked Wisdom Sample and eBook
  • Art
  • About
    • Contact
  • 0

    No products in the cart.

  • Instagram

    Instagram did not return a 200.
logo logo
  • What I do
    • Design Thinking
    • Wicked Problems
    • Studio thinking
  • Work With Me
    • Courses
    • Consulting
    • Keynotes
    • One-on-one
  • Who I work with
  • Videos
  • Articles
  • FREE E-Book
  • Shop
    • Working From Home Book
    • WIcked Wisdom Book
      • Wicked Wisdom Sample and eBook
  • Art
  • About
    • Contact
  • 0

    No products in the cart.

Botoxing Brands: the magnetic power of genuineness over perfection

By mofox

Just when you think you’ve seen everything, you go to a school reunion. At the last one I attended, we all gleefully got to play ‘who on earth is that?’ An awesome testament to the powers of surgical transformation and personal chutzpa, our mystery classmate commanded the spotlight as she did the mwa-mwa tour of the room, dragging everyone’s helplessly mesmerised gaze with her. Only when I heard her speak could I work out who she was, and then the game of finding any remotely familiar features was on. Utterly riveting. Amanda (appropriately enough, not her real name) had morphed from a scrawny, awkward, unkempt and rather odd girl into a buxom, pouty lacquered vision of… what must have been someone’s vision of a middle-aged barbie doll. Unreal. In every sense.

What was particularly striking however was that as fascinating as she was, people didn’t see her as a ‘who’, but rather as a ‘what’ – as a curiosity. It’s hard to build a meaningful relationship on those terms. But then brands have been doing that for years.

When I was dragged up through the strategic hallways of JWT, we were instructed to think of a brand as a person, theoretically complete with quirks and foibles to make it warm, unique and accessible. Of course this was a farce. Putting aside the debate over whether a concept or construct can ever be that 3 dimensionally human, the process by which this humanity was supposed to be inferred ensured it was a non-starter to begin with. Rather like expecting Six Sigma to foster innovation in a corporate environment. Take a functional product or service, get a committee to fill in forms with laundry-lists of characteristics based on what they thought it ‘should’ be or that they thought would appeal to ‘the market, water it down so it will exclude no one, package it up with a nice 30 sec TVC that brings those characteristics to life and presto! Vanilla Frankenstein Ken Dolls masquerading as psychotically friendly bank managers weaving themselves into the milestones of our lives, Stepford mums twinkling over laundry stains and dirty toilets, and endless immaculate young couples oozing love and dental perfection whilst traveling the world and shopping enthusiastically for insurance. (Why can’t banks market their perfectly valuable services without having to worm their way into our hearts and bar-mitzvahs? Particularly since we all know they’ll eat our children if there’s a whiff of financial hardship on the horizon.)

A fascinating feat of strategic surgical engineering perhaps, but hardly magnetically attractive. ‘Perfection’ never is.

Little has changed, which is a pity. The most magnetic brands are still those like Apple, Maui Jim, or Twitter that are determinedly themselves, that do not emerge slickly formed and beautifully botoxed for mass consumption, but start by standing for something real, then grow organically through interactions with the market (usually niche at first) they naturally appeal to. They have artistry because their creation – co-creation in fact – seems seamless and elegant rather than produced and imposed. Brands essentially only exist in the minds of the consumer or marketplace. It is an illusion to think they can be controlled by their ‘maker’ – particularly in an era where on-line word of mouth rules.

Amanda’s perfect plasticity didn’t make her appealing. But then, perhaps her niche lay elsewhere. And ‘who’ now lived behind the ‘what’ she’d become was destined to remain a mystery. Once she finished her whirlwind tour of the room, she ran out of things to say.

Next time I looked around, she’d disappeared.

artistry, brands, transformation

mofox

Previous Bite the Plate: accidents breed innovation
Next Change Mutiny: it’s not what we should do but what we’re willing to do that matters.

Related Posts

Worm Dervish Revolution

September 29, 2009

Creative Structure: Skeletons In The Closet

March 8, 2011

Perception Is The Root Of All Error

June 2, 2010

Living Art: how art can help you create a meaningful life.

December 15, 2021

Comment

There is no comment on this post. Be the first one.

Leave a comment or Cancel Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • mo-laughing

  • Mo Fox helps companies get quick, ingenious breakthroughs using the resources they already have and what makes them unique to get practical results that stick. Or else she teaches them how to do it themselves using hybrid methodologies that fuse art and design with business processes to help people rediscover and leverage their innate creativity. Why? So they become much more effective in the way they think and how they do things. Because that's where their value and competitive edge is. And that’s when they light up and love what they do.
  • Terms and Conditions

    Contact

    Subscribe

© 2016 mofox.com. All rights reserved.
  • What I do
    • Design Thinking
    • Wicked Problems
    • Studio thinking
  • Work With Me
    • Courses
    • Consulting
    • Keynotes
    • One-on-one
  • Who I work with
  • Videos
  • Articles
  • FREE E-Book
  • Shop
    • Working From Home Book
    • WIcked Wisdom Book
      • Wicked Wisdom Sample and eBook
  • Art
  • About
    • Contact